Welcome To Topix Too Forum

Just read the wiki on it, on the face it looks like self D to me. A bit radical but as I was taught, be careful who you pick a fight with.  At worst, involuntary manslaughter. 

And then we have the age issue again....

Everyone who testified has said Anthony was the aggressor. All he had to do was leave a tent that he wasn't suppose to be, as a matter of fact, he shouldn't have even been on school grounds as he had been banned. Someone dropped the ball and didn't get him off the grounds. The age issue plays no part. He was 17 and killed a 17 year old. He should have known the difference between right and wrong and he chose not to abide by that.

First of all, let’s be perfectly clear; I never once stated Karmelo Anthony wasn’t guilty. Further, I never once condoned his actions. I merely attempted to shed light on the possible state of mind of the suspect at the time the incident occurred.

Ok so Anthony was known to have possessed a knife or a weapon. He had previously been caught with a weapon. That doesn’t make him a murderer. He claimed he was acting in self defense because Austin Metcalf had “put his hands on him”. In my opinion, that is an act of provocation. If someone deliberately puts their hands on me in a threatening manner, you can bet I’m gonna do whatever I can to defend myself. Now, it’s not in my nature to pull a weapon and do bodily harm. First and foremost, I’m not a fan of blood. It tends to make me feel weak in the knees.

As far as the parents not being able to ever visit with their child again. Unfortunately, I know all too well how that feels. The circumstances are different but the outcome is the same.

I am not judge or jury. While this may not be a black/white issue, in reality, it is. Every single time there’s a situation that involves blacks/whites, it will become a racial issue. We may never be able to abolish that mindset.

I hate to see or hear about a young man losing his life. In addition, I hate to see a young man spend 35 years in prison. Prison will strip him of any decency he may have possessed.

There’s simply no good outcome for this crime.

I don’t deny you, your right to an opinion. I don’t persecute you for having an opinion. I fail to see Karmelo Anthony as a “punk”. I see him as a frightened young man realizing he acted in a rash and terrifying manner. He can’t undo what he’s done. No amount of prison time will replace the life he stole. 35 years or 100 years in prison will not rehabilitate Karmelo Anthony. His life is ruined and he’ll never get it back.

Everyone who testified stated Anthiny was the aggressor in this provocation. Had this been a white kid killing a black kid, you can just about guess everyone would want him hung out to dry so to speak.

1160

Culpable

Masquerade